Skip to main content

Table 7 Summary of body mass, external body and craniodental measurements, and results of one-way ANOVAs and Tukey post hoc tests for Hipposideros commersoni based on the molecular clades defined in this study

From: Cryptic diversity in Hipposideros commersoni sensu stricto (Chiroptera: Hipposideridae) in the western portion of Madagascar

Variable

 

Clade A

Clade C

Clade B

One-way ANOVA

Post hoc Tukey tests

     

F(2, 16)

P

 

TL

    

6.50

0.01

P = 0.03;

       

Clade B < C

 

N

2

9

8

   
 

Mean

121.0

133.6

125.6

   
 

Std. Deviation

-

4.50

7.23

   
 

Minimum

119

125

115

   
 

Maximum

123

138

137

   

TAIL

    

7.03

0.006

P = 0.006;

       

Clade B < C

 

N

2

9

8

   
 

Mean

32

36.8

31.0

   
 

Std. Deviation

-

2.91

3.66

   
 

Minimum

30

31

25

   
 

Maximum

34

41

35

   

HF

    

1.51

ns

ns

 

N

2

9

8

   
 

Mean

14.5

15.8

14.8

   
 

Std. Deviation

0.71

0.44

1.98

   
 

Minimum

14

15

13

   
 

Maximum

15

16

18

   

EAR

    

10.16

0.01

P = 0.02;

       

Clade B < C

 

N

2

9

8

   
 

Mean

26.5

30.7

28.6

   
 

Std. Deviation

-

0.71

1.85

   
 

Minimum

26

30

26

   
 

Maximum

27

32

31

   

FA

    

6.41

0.009

P = 0.02;

       

Clade B < C

 

N

2

9

8

   
 

Mean

80.5

86.4

82.3

   
 

Std. Deviation

-

2.88

2.96

   
 

Minimum

80

82

79

   
 

Maximum

81

91

87

   

WT

    

0.20

ns

ns

 

N

2

9

8

   
 

Mean

40.5

42.11

39.69

   
 

Std. Deviation

-

5.07

7.40

   
 

Minimum

26

30

29

   
 

Maximum

55

47

49

   
     

F(2, 14)

P

 

SL

    

9.82

0.002

P = 0.011;

       

Clade B < C

 

N

2

8

7

   
 

Mean

26.95

29.72

28.08

   
 

Std. Deviation

-

0.67

1.20

   
 

Minimum

26.5

28.2

26.6

   
 

Maximum

27.4

30.5

29.9

   

CBL

    

9.68

0.002

P = 0.009;

       

Clade B < C

 

N

2

8

7

   
 

Mean

23.9

26.34

24.78

   
 

Std. Deviation

-

0.60

1.12

   
 

Minimum

23.6

25.1

23.4

   
 

Maximum

24.2

27.1

26.6

   

ZYGO

  

6.32

0.01

ns

  
 

N

2

8

7

   
 

Mean

14.1

15.65

14.83

   
 

Std. Deviation

-

0.59

0.64

   
 

Minimum

13.6

15

14.1

   
 

Maximum

14.6

16.8

15.8

   

IOW

    

0.36

ns

ns

 

N

2

8

7

   
 

Mean

2.9

3.01

2.93

   
 

Std. Deviation

-

0.13

0.26

   
 

Minimum

2.6

2.8

2.6

   
 

Maximum

3.2

3.2

3.3

   

MAST

  

5.91

0.034

  

P = 0.014;

       

Clade B < C

 

N

2

8

7

   
 

Mean

12.2

13.67

12.91

   
 

Std. Deviation

-

0.51

0.69

   
 

Minimum

11.7

12.9

12.2

   
 

Maximum

12.7

14.4

13.9

   

ROST

    

4.34

0.034

P = 0.038;

       

Clade B < C

 

N

2

8

7

   
 

Mean

10.95

11.70

10.94

   
 

Std. Deviation

-

0.38

0.68

   
 

Minimum

10.7

11

10.1

   
 

Maximum

11.2

12.1

12

   

PAL

    

4.34

0.028

ns

 

N

2

8

7

   
 

Mean

3.65

4.47

4.07

   
 

Std. Deviation

-

0.27

0.43

   
 

Minimum

3.2

4

3.7

   
 

Maximum

4.1

4.8

4.9

   

C1-M3

    

10.97

0.001

P = 0.004;

       

Clade B < C

 

N

2

8

7

   
 

Mean

9.45

10.55

9.79

   
 

Std. Deviation

-

0.26

0.50

   
 

Minimum

9.3

10

9.3

   
 

Maximum

9.6

10.8

10.8

   

UP MOL R

    

9.79

0.002

P = 0.003;

       

Clade B < C

 

N

2

8

7

   
 

Mean

7.35

7.87

7.36

   
 

Std. Deviation

-

0.17

0.31

   
 

Minimum

7.3

7.6

7

   
 

Maximum

7.4

8.2

8

   

C1-C1

    

11.69

0.001

P = 0.002;

       

Clade B < C

 

N

2

8

7

   
 

Mean

6.90

8.16

7.17

   
 

Std. Deviation

-

0.46

0.45

   
 

Minimum

6.6

7.3

6.7

   
 

Maximum

7.2

8.7

7.9

   

M3-M3

    

7.33

0.007

P = 0.011;

       

Clade B < C

 

N

2

8

7

   
 

Mean

9.85

10.82

10.03

   
 

Std. Deviation

-

0.24

0.64

   
 

Minimum

9.7

10.4

9.2

   
 

Maximum

10

11.1

11

   

UP CANIN

    

4.50

0.031

ns

 

N

2

8

7

   
 

Mean

4.35

5.09

4.60

   
 

Std. Deviation

-

0.26

0.45

   
 

Minimum

3.9

4.7

3.8

   
 

Maximum

4.8

5.4

5.3

   

DENT LEN

    

8.46

0.004

P = 0.011;

       

Clade B < C

 

N

2

8

7

   
 

Mean

17.75

19.57

18.33

   
 

Std. Deviation

-

0.48

0.95

   
 

Minimum

17.6

18.5

17.1

   
 

Maximum

17.9

20

19.6

   

MOM1 COR

    

4.01

0.042

ns

 

N

2

8

7

   
 

Mean

5.65

6.22

5.76

   
 

Std. Deviation

-

0.21

0.49

   
 

Minimum

5.5

6.0

5.0

   
 

Maximum

5.8

6.6

6.4

   

I1-M3

    

7.78

0.005

P = 0.014;

       

Clade B < C

 

N

2

8

7

   
 

Mean

11.75

12.99

12.13

   
 

Std. Deviation

-

0.30

0.70

   
 

Minimum

11.6

12.5

11.1

   
 

Maximum

11.9

13.3

13.2

   

LOWER TR

    

11.20

0.001

P = 0.003;

       

Clade B < C

 

N

2

8

7

   
 

Mean

10.70

11.87

10.97

   
 

Std. Deviation

-

0.27

0.57

   
 

Minimum

10.5

11.5

10.2

   
 

Maximum

10.9

12.2

11.9

   
  1. See materials and methods for definitions of variable acronyms. ns = not significant